Seattlest Vote 2008 Poll: I-1000

Initiative I-1000 is the Death With Dignity Initiative that would allow end-stage, terminally ill patients to have access to prescribed life-ending medication. The Times elegantly argues, "On the grounds of compassion for the suffering, and recognition of the individual as a moral agent, death with dignity is a right that should be allowed." Attorney Margaret Dore objects to I-1000's exact phrasing because it "would put vulnerable persons at risk of abuse (and worse) at the hands of others." And finally, local doctors are ambivalent.

And you? How do you feel about it? Comments welcome, and our poll closes tomorrow at 2 p.m. More about I-1000 here.

How do you plan to vote on I-1000, the Death With Dignity Initiative? ( surveys)

Contact the author of this article or email tips@seattlest.com with further questions, comments or tips.

By Katelyn in Miscellaneous on October 31, 2008 1:45 PM

Comments [rss]

MargaretDore

Your blog’s description of my position is not accurate. I am opposed to I-1000 because it is a recipe for elder abuse. You can read I-1000 for yourself at http://www.secstate.wa.gov/elections/initiatives/text/i1000.pdf.

I-1000 allows someone with a financial interest in dad's estate, help him apply for the lethal dose. That person is even allowed to witness the request form and talk for him. (I-1000, Sections 3, 22 & 1(3)). This person could be an adult child or a new “best friend.” Would it really be “dad's choice” with that person standing there urging him on, incidentally securing his own inheritance?

The biggest problem is that I-1000 does not require a witness at the death. This creates the opportunity for someone to administer the lethal dose to dad without his consent. Even if he struggled violently, who would know? I-1000 would give the perfect alibi.

Family members often have their own agendas and may also have financial interests that dovetail with a patient’s death. In Oregon, the majority of patients who have used its law have been “well educated” with private insurance. http://www.oregon.gov/DHS/ph/pas/docs/year10.pdf In other words, people with money.

Was it really their “choice?” Vote “no” on I-1000.

Margaret Dore

Law Offices of Margaret K. Dore, P.S.

www.margaretdore.com

1001 4th Avenue, 44th Floor

Seattle, WA 98154

206 389 1754