Quantcast

Seattlest Book Club: The Worst Hard Time, The End?

dustbowlmotherindoor.JPG
THIS MONTH we've been talking about Seattle author Timothy Egan's The Worst Hard Time. We went over the big plow-up of the prairie, the hard-scrabble living, and Egan's decision to tell the story novelistically, rather than textbookily.

NEXT MONTH we're reading Seattle native Pauls Toutonghi's novel Red Weather. To join in, visit Bailey Coy Books on Capitol Hill, or Santoro's Books in Greenwood, and ask for the Seattlest Book Club discount. That's right, a discount. Because you're loved.

So to wrap up! We've been thinking about how Egan no doubt intended that we compare the Dust Bowl's human-driven climate change with global warming -- maybe not so much compare, even, as see the one as an offshoot of the other. There's still a lot of work being done, 80 years post-Dust Bowl, on prairie restoration. There are still ideologues like the Dalhart Texan's editor John McCarty, who wanted people to focus on the upside of dust storms. As global warming comes to seem more and more a sure thing (whether you think it human-driven or not) there's strategizing about its effects. Progressives still have big plans, while well-meant agricultural subsidies still create huge environmental, economic, and political effects.

We're not heartened, to put it mildly. And we haven't even gotten into the bees vs. cell phones thing. How far are we from being this woman and her family? Do we really know? And would we do anything about it if we did? Why is it that we are so prone both to ignoring worst-case scenarios and repressing them when they do occur? We're full of questions, not so many answers. Thanks, Mr. Egan. We'll send you the bill for the Lunesta.

Contact the author of this article or email tips@seattlest.com with further questions, comments or tips.

Comments [rss]

  • Seth

    Um, yeah, a parable is about the most explicit you can be without actually being explicit.

    Glad he didn't cave to the editor though, it would've felt like an add-on. In Simon Winchester's book Krakatoa (released not long after 9/11), he included a chapter at the end of the book where he tried to tie the Krakatoa explosion to the rise of Muslim fundamentalism. It was truly embarrassing.

  • MvB

    Seth: Yeah, I got that Collapse vibe, too. I remember that Diamond pointed out it was usually something societies were good at -- TOO good at, were overly dependent on -- that screwed them eventually (hunting, tree-chopping), so it's always difficult to back off the throttle just when you need to.

    David: I think I can concede there's a difference between an outright parallel (It's the SAME DAMN thing all over again!) and a parable (this is a cautionary tale, draw your own cautions). It's like Vietnam/Iraq -- people get bogged down trying to parallel detail with detail when the question is: "Have we started something we can't finish?"

  • David F.

    In this interview, Egan said he didn't want to draw the parallel to global warming:

    "Some people think there's a parallel to what's going to happen with global warming. I'm not sure I'll go that step....[M]y editor wanted to push me into that. I wanted to stick with the story. I wanted to let the story tell itself, like a parable, and lay it out and let people see what's obvious. I didn't think I needed to draw in the global warming."


    Actually, that's confusing. Not parallel, but a parable?

  • Seth

    If this were a college class, we'd be reading Collapse by Jared Diamond next. If you read it you learn that massive human-caused environmental disasters are usually sudden and unexpectedly harsh. Yes, we are the most mighty food-producing society ever, but we still can't really predict the weather. If we got a year of rain, for instance, we'd all be just as fucked as the lady above. Or a worldwide drought, or whatever. I don't want to end up like her, but I know I might, so enjoy every minute...

    In a way, I feel we've circled back to Raban's book, where a sudden disaster destroys our world as we know it...in his case it was a geologic one, but it could just as easily by climatological...and as the waters rose up over I-5, can't you imagine Frank Blethen looking on the bright side? Hey--at least the Viaduct problem would finally be solved.

blog comments powered by Disqus

send a tip

tips@seattlest.com