Abandon Ship! Mariner Front Office Makes Awful, Awful Trade

300px-Iceberg_and_titanic.pngThree years ago, we all hoped for aging middle infielder Omar Vizquel to fail a physical so the M's wouldn't complete an agreed-upon deal for him. And our pleas were heard.

Well, M's fans, break out your prayers to the patron saint of aged middle infielders failing physicals again, because we need another favor from him. Pending a physical, the M's are going to deal two good young prospects, Chris Snelling and Emiliano Fruto, for the Nationals' Jose Vidro, a once-power hitting middle infielder who has suddenly hit for a lot less power since 2003 or so if you catch our meaning.

We defended the Soriano/Ramirez deal, and we try whenever possible to give the M's front office the benefit of the doubt, but this trade is horrible. USS Mariner explains why using...STATS!:

Chris Snelling is a 25-year old corner outfielder with an injury history and a plus arm who hit .250/.360/.427. Based on his PECOTA projections, he’s one of the best hitting prospects in baseball. He was the third or fourth-best hitter on the team last year (performance, not taking playing time into account).

Fruto’s a 22-year old reliever. He’s a big boy. He’s got a ridiculous change and through his whole career in the minors he was as stingy giving up the home run as you could possibly hope for.

Jose Vidro is a 31-yr old second baseman who hit .289/.348/.395 for the Nationals last year.

Lookout Landing is having a breakdown:


My hands are shaking uncontrollably right now as I sit in my chair.

Bill Bavasi needs to go, and he needs to go last month.

We've turned this deal around in our head over and over to try to justify it, and it just makes no sense. Put Vidro at 1B and trade Sexson? Maybe, but Vidro has a huge salary, so you aren't saving any money, and Snelling would hit better from there anyway! Does this have to do with the Betancourt smuggling case? There's no way anything would happen during the season--and the players haven't been charged with anything, anyway.

USS Mariner commenters, never a stable bunch to begin with, are variously threatening to murder, blackmail, and engage in sexual congress with GM Bill Bavasi.

The only possible sane explanation is that Lopez is to be dealt as part of a larger deal. We find that hard to believe, though--these deals don't usually happen piece-meal. We'll be on our knees in front of the holiday tree all night.

Comments (11) [rss]

There is nothing- absolutely nothing- that can save this trade. Unless Lopez and Sexson can be flipped for Manny Ramirez and Bob Gibson circa 1968 will this be anything but a disaster for this team.

Fire Bavasi. Fire him now.

user-pic

Fire him? That's too good. We need something much more grisly. And hire Dick Wiliams, damnit. That's what this ballclub needs: Brimstone! Unless he's dead. Then never mind.

user-pic

I have just woken up and read about this and I think I am going to be sick. I want to throw up now. I am struggling to put two sentences together. I just cannot believe this. This is why people should be fired BEFORE they become desperate on the job.

user-pic

This now looks like the worst offseason in the history of the club. It again shows that Bavasi has no idea of how to be a GM.

Even if you wanted to move Soriano, or Snelling, or Fruto, your job is to get value for those players. Bavasi is not getting anything near market value.

He just got fleeced by Jim Bowden for fucks sake. Will, I am to am ill.

user-pic

Having taken a few minutes to gather myself, stop breathing from my mouth, and wipe the agony away... I still can't believe it.

Possible title for future blog posts on this trade, in the theme of, "Everyone Hates Soriano for Ramirez, etc...":

"Everyone Hates"

user-pic

You're right--should've been "Everyone Hates Snelling for Vidro, and So Do We"

user-pic

Our only hope is that Putin is a Mariners fan.

user-pic

Heh. I'm happy the M's passed on Vizquel. He has been rock-solid in the Giants infield these last two seasons. His bat ain't great, but he's been healthy, capable, and one of the most exciting and fun players to watch on the team. One of the best signings our team has made.

I knew you M's fans were in trouble when Bavasi was hired. He's running the team into the ground.

However, the REAL problem there isn't Bavasi - it's Howard Lincoln.

user-pic

Vidro is a DH...

I read an article somewhere today and mr Vidro said that this was an IDEAL situation for him so he could be an every day DH... his knee was too bad to be an everyday player in the field.... so contemplating trading Lopez is a HORIBLE IDEA YOU SHOULD FORGET BEFORE BAVASI PICKS UP ON THE PSYCIC WAVES AND DECIDES THAT IS A GREAT IDEA

so we have FIVE DH's.... Ibanez, Sexson, Broussard, Guillen, and now Vidro... a DF... Willie Bloomquist... W! T! F!

crap...

and trading Soriano for ramirez... damn it...

it all reminds me of Woody's '97 string... where he traded Jose Cruz Jr.... for Timlin... then followed that up by dumping Lowe AND Veritek for heathcliffe slocumb... anybody else just vomit?

get ready... they have to trade Ichiro before his contract is up... cause he dang sure aint gonna re-sign here... if he's staring at a 5 year rebuilding process... (BTW THAT will be the last act of Bavasi... Lincoln will order him to trade Ichiro then once the ink is dry... they'll fire bavasi.... mark my words)

then they'll hire wally walker to find a new GM... havent we been here before?

can we bring back jeff smulyan? please!!!

Bavasi is making Woodward look like Billy Beane.

I don't understand what the Mariners were thinking on this deal, and I'm a Nationals' fan. Most of us thought that we'd be lucky to find a team to take Vidro for two non-prospects if we covered half his salary.

Perhaps Snelling & Fruto will be solid major leaguers, maybe not. But we got out from under Vidro's salary, and that's all we were hoping for.

Now, don't feel too bad. Vidro can still hit when he's healthy. He's hit .377 the past two Aprils, but wear-and-tear drops his batting average as if there were an anchor attached.

What might Vidro do as your DH? Based on watching him the past two seasons, I'd say you can look forward to something like: .295-15-90 (if he bats third). We don't feel like we lost that offensive production because he's not able to hit like that and play second.

I think he'll make Mariners' fans happy, though I think Bowden would have given him up for a nobody minor leaguer.

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Seattlest

Seattlest is a website about Seattle. More

Editor: Michael van Baker Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Seattlest.

All Our RSS