"Welcome to the Metropolitan Market Café!"

That was the greeting we received when we rounded the corner to the front lobby of said market. That and a giant, bland sign listing the coffee drinks this new "café" will be selling. "Are you fucking kidding me?" is what we wanted to say to the lady behind the counter, wearing a sparkling clean apron and Lisa Loeb glasses. Instead, we rolled our glazed eyes from her face up to the strips of brown butcher paper covering most of the logo of our favorite Seattle coffee establishment. "We'd better still be asleep," we said, not really under our breath. "And this'd better be a nightmare."

No_Peets.png

No more Peet's Coffee at the new lower Queen Anne Metropolitan Market. Oh shit. No. More. Peet's.

We sort of knew this was going to happen, what with the hoopla of Larry's Markets being suddenly sold off to the highest bidders earlier this year. And the transition from Larry's to Metro had begun in earnest, with the signage changing, and then specific sections of the store being tucked away behind murky plastic sheeting. And there was the nice display table set up in the lobby, right beside Peet's, as a matter of fact, where large signs and fancy comment cards encouraged patrons to give the new ownership their two cents—"Tell us what you'd like to see!" Or something like that.

We know all this because we dropped into the store to get coffee four out of five weekday mornings. Because we love Peet's Coffee. Because it's the best fucking coffee we've found anywhere, and far superior to the brew our local world-dominating-mega-roaster pours. (Yes, Caffe Ladro, yours is next on the list. But we'd love you more if you didn't make us listen to your lame barista-gossip while we waited in line.)

Numb, we take out our wallet and stare at our recently charged Peet's card (it was Friday—just three days ago, when Peet's still existed), heavy with 20 electric, worthless dollars. We look up from our wallet to Lisa- Loeb-in-an-Apron and must have been pale-faced with shock. "Don't worry, this one's on us," she says.

It's a small consolation, and initiates an embarrassing exchange: Lisa says they haven't figured out their coffee makers yet—that one of them brews too strong, and the other too weak. They haven't figured out the right combo of ground beans to water, in other words. Not a good sign for this new establishment. That's okay, we say, still in disbelief. Whatever, we think, none of this matters now. Life is over. We're then presented with four cups of coffee (and find that their "small" is indeed, literally, very small): two of them are the "strong" brew, and the other two the "weak." We told Lisa that we favor strong coffee, but apparently that didn't matter. So we grab a couple of lids and find that they're too big. They'd fit a normal small cup, but not these tiny things. Oh, Lisa says, we still have Peet's lids out here. Ours are in the back. And she makes to run back there to retrieve them. Feeling the knife twist in our guts, we tell her we could just pour this stuff into a larger cup. Look, the larger cups you have right there. She says good idea! and hands over four bigger cups. Oh, good Christ.

When this is behind us, and we're back on the road to work (with half-full cups of strong/weak coffee that taste like cardboard ass), we repeatedly recount what just happened, and lament the loss of the best coffee (despite its grocery store kiosk-ness) in Queen Anne. What really pisses us off about this development? We wrote a little something in one of those Metro comment cards, something that was obviously ignored.

"Please, whatever you do, for the LOVE OF GOD," we wrote, "Don’t get rid of Peet's Coffee."

Email This Entry


Comments (13) [rss]

I feel your pain. There is NO coffee like Peets. Strong, rich and the most satisfying cup in Seattle. SUCH A LOSS. At least you can use your card at the Fremont location. I keep emailing Peets and begging for more locations here! I share in your loss and will be wearing a Peets coffee sleeve on my arm for solidarity!

It might be too soon to try to replace your loved one with someone new, but have you tried El Diablo? I know it's a climb up the hill, but it's really good stuff.

Personally, I can't stand Peet's coffee. Nasty, disgusting crap I used to drink black daily at my old job. It's a possibility that my opinion of Peet's coffee's flavor was affected by my dismal job, but I would say it's equally possible that I hated my job because of the crappy coffee. It certainly didn't help. So I can't really share your pain.

Jeremy, I agree with you. Peet's is awful. Yeah, the Ladro on QA has gone downhill but the others are still great (the one on 1st & Union is great). Better coffee in Seattle; try Umbria, Vivace, Top Pot, Zeitgeist. Man there are a ton of places with better coffee than Peet's.

I have to say, the coffee that I make for myself every morning is always really fucking good and i know the barista won't give me any guff. Am I the only person in Seattle who actually makes their own at home?

Jeebus, get a grip.
It's coffee.
And your card isn't worthless. Bike/walk/bus to Fremont or Green Lake.

Clint,

All is not lost...Try Pura Vida's Cafe "K"...Just like Alfred used to roast...

I gotta agree with the "ZOMG PEETS BLOWS!!!!!1" comments.. except, maybe not so extremely. Its good in a latte, but the brew at the Fremont branch is far, far too strong and acidic for drinking straight; even in a watery americano its just bitter and cutting to /my/ tongue. YMMV

Like or hate Peets coffee, calling it the best on Queen Anne is just silly or ignorant. Off the top of my head, I can think of four places on QA that have better coffee than Pete's or Ladro. I'm glad Larry's is gone. I was bummed when the Hansen Baking Company closed to make room for Larry's, now there was something to be crying about.

To the gentleman who drank bad coffee at work, please blame your office equipment not Peet's. We get Peet's here at our office, and the technician ensure the water to coffee ration is done perfect. As long as peet's continues to roast and ship within 24 hours (something not ONE of the other companies mentioned here do) they will reign supreme. Also, you cannot beat a cup brewed at the Peet's store - if you find one too strong or acidic, have you TOLD the barista??? They will recommend, and even specially brew, a cup of a different coffee. I personally find Major Dickason's to be the perfect cup.

[Courtney] I'm with you. Once you figure out how to make a really good cup of coffee, the best coffee shop in Seattle is home. Now you just have to figure out who roasts the best beans*...

* Generally the absolute best come from the best coffee shops, though Costco house blend is actually quite good.

Seattleites passionate about coffee—who knew? I make it (with Peet’s beans) at home on the weekends, and although it’s good, it just doesn’t have that full-bodied flavor that you get from the coffeehouse. It’s probably psychological. Just like getting pissed off about not being able to find good coffee on the way to work. Or maybe that’s laziness.

Looks like I’ve got a few cups to try, and a couple of people to picket Metro with.

Love the coffee sleeve, K. If your arm goes numb, go ahead and take if off.

News for QA Peets' fans: I'm sitting in El Diablo on top of Queen Anne hill, someone just came in who saw that they are putting in a Peets where the Ravenna Gardens place used to be at the corner of Queen Anne Ave. and Boston, across from Starbucks / Tullys and next to the Ladro.

(MEANWHILE, I read in the paper earlier this week that they are putting in a Top Pot donuts on Galer, a block down from the Trader Joe....)

Post a comment (Comment Policy)

Tips

About Seattlest

Seattlest is a website about Seattle. More

Editor: Regis Lacher Publisher: Gothamist

Contribute

Latest Tip:

In Woodinville there's a hole-in-the-wall charcuterie named Bill The Butcher which has the most outl
[more]

Latest Photo:

Recent Comments

Subscribe

Use an RSS reader to stay up to date with the latest news and posts from Seattlest.

All Our RSS